by Susan Martin, "Welcoming Immigrants to Washington" study co-author; Board of Directors, LWV of Washington
The growth in immigrant detention often slips under the radar.
Between 65,000 and 70,000 immigrants — and some citizens — are held in detention on any single day, most by ICE and a lesser number by Customs and Border Protection, the other major immigration enforcement agency.
Although that number is below the approximate 110,000 total the president wants, the level is far higher than the 40,000 or fewer who were detained per day under prior administrations.
More than 70% of the immigrants who are detained have no criminal convictions, according to the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, founded at Syracuse University. Most of the remaining immigrants were convicted for minor offenses, such as traffic violations, or for immigration only offences.
In 2025, the so-called One Big Beautiful Bill Act allocated $45 billion to ICE to expand adult and family immigration detention capacity through fiscal year 2029. The legislation made it easier to detain families for longer periods of time, overriding prior laws and legal agreements that provided a 20-day limit for children to be detained. It also allowed ICE to use facilities that were not licensed for childcare.
Human and social costs of detention are substantial, particularly for children. The economic costs are also staggering.

The Government Accountability Office*, an independent agency in the legislative branch of the federal government — often referred to as the Congressional Watchdog—has accused ICE of implementing “detention expansion initiatives without developing a comprehensive strategic plan to guide its efforts. For example, ICE has not developed consistent goals or objectives for the size and characteristics of its detention bed space.”
Furthermore, ICE lost significant amounts of money through neglect or incompetence. For example, ICE spent $7.7 million between January and April 2026 on zoning assessments, title insurance and other nonrecoverable costs to purchase seven warehouses that it now intends to sell. The government continues to pay for utilities, security, and other services at these warehouses. According to the GAO report, taxpayers spent about $12.8 million on these services as of August 2026.
Furthermore, GAO determined that ICE had not assessed “the risks and benefits of using facilities with high operating costs compared to other less costly options.”
Indeed, physical detention is much more expensive than alternatives that often lead to better outcomes for immigrants and the government.
Prior to this administration, ICE supported alternatives that enable “aliens (sic) to remain in their communities — contributing to their families and community organizations and, as appropriate, concluding their affairs in the U.S. — as they move through immigration proceedings or prepare for departure.” The alternatives include case management, e.g., reminding people of their court appearance date, and technology tools, e.g., ankle bracelets or wrist-worn devices. After the change in administration, the message about alternatives now reads: This information is archived and not reflective of current practice.
Washington state is not immune to the dangers of detention. Increasingly, friends and neighbors have been picked up by ICE or other enforcement agencies and been sent to the Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma. The center is one of the larger detention facilities in the country, covering must of the Pacific Northwest.
Conditions in the center, which is owned and managed by the for-profit GEO Group, which has numerous contracts with ICE, have been problematic for years, as is the case nationally. Medical neglect, sexual assault, poor sanitation practices, inedible food, use of force, and solitary confinement are among the problems faced by detainees nationwide.
Detention has a place in immigration policy. It may be needed, in particular, to determine that a new, unauthorized arrival poses no harm to others.
How this administration is using detention, however, is well beyond what is necessary to keep our country safe. The election is a good time to remind members of Congress that physical detention should be the exception — and not the rule.
*The author of this op-ed is a member of the Comptroller General’s Advisory Board at the Government Accountability Office.